Sometimes Questionable, Sensationalized History
Release Date: October 08, 2010
Starring: Aaron Johnson, Kristen Scott
Thomas, Anne-Marie Duff,
Thomas Brodie Sangster, David
Morrissey, and David Threlfall
Genre: Semi-Biographical Drama
Runtime: 98 minutes
Distributor: The Weinstein Company
Director: Sam Taylor-Wood
Executive Producer: None
Producer: Douglas Rae, Robert Bernstein
and Kevin Loader
Writer: Matt Greenhalgh
Address Comments To:Bob and Harvey Weinstein, Co-Chairmen
The Weinstein Company
345 Hudson Street, 13th Floor
New York, NY 10014
Phone: (646) 862-3400; Fax: (917) 368-7000
The movie opens when John is about 14. John has been raised by his stern, reserved Aunt Mimi and her more outgoing husband, George, since he was young. After George suddenly drops dead, John sneaks out of the house to visit his estranged mother, Julia’s, home. The movie (falsely, we might add) indicates John hasn’t seen his mother since he was little and that he is surprised to learn from his cousin that she lives nearby.
As John gets to know his mother again, the movie hints that John has incestuous feelings toward his mother that he has trouble handling. Also, his mother is a flirtatious woman, even though she and her common-law husband have two little daughters. Eventually, John and Julia establish a more normal mother-son relationship as John starts to grow into his teenage years. She teaches John how to play the banjo and gets him interested in music, to the chagrin of John’s more practical aunt.
John decides to found the Quarrymen band, which later became The Beatles, with some high school friends, then meeting and adding Paul McCartney and George Harrison later. Meanwhile, John works hard to reconcile his aunt and his mother. Both women became estranged when John’s aunt started raising John while his father virtually abandoned the family, moving to New Zealand, and his mother got involved with other men.
Then, John gets jealous when Julia seems to flirt with other guys, including Paul and her own husband. This causes violent outbursts from John. Just when John starts to get over that jealousy, tragedy strikes. Happily, Paul, who has gone through some childhood traumas of his own, and Aunt Mimi are there to comfort him.
The reconciliation scenes in NOWHERE BOY are very powerful. There is also a great scene where John encourages his aunt and mother to reconcile by giving them a powerful short lecture on love. These scenes may remind Beatles fans of the more uplifting, inspiring parts of Lennon and McCartney’s music extolling transcendent love.
Regrettably, however, NOWHERE BOY contains strong sexual content, including the disturbing incest theme running through the movie. The only evidence for this theme, however, is a brief tape recording by John that, during one encounter with his mother at age 14, he had a brief incestuous thought about her. And, this recording came after John had had years of Freudian psychological therapy, which usually focuses on incest. The movie could have deleted this historically questionable theme without giving up any of its other dramatic effects. NOWHERE BOY also contains plenty of strong obscenities as well as somewhat disturbing violence.
Adult viewers, therefore, should approach NOWHERE BOY with extreme caution. In fact, many adult moviegoers probably will find that the positive aspects in NOWHERE BOY don’t justify having had to sit through the movie’s more offensive, disturbing qualities.
Finally, although the story of how John’s aunt and uncle ended up raising him is apparently true, John actually began making frequent trips to his mother’s nearby home when he was 11, not 14. That was also when John’s mother began teaching him about rock and roll and training him on the banjo she owned. Here, it is also interesting to note one comment about the movie made by Quarrymen co-founder Collin Hanton: “I don’t remember swearing that much!”
These facts indicate there’s far too much sensationalized revisionist history in NOWHERE BOY. It reflects a lack of trust by the filmmakers in their own subject.
The reconciliation scenes in NOWHERE BOY are very powerful. There is also a great scene where Lennon gives a short lecture on love when his mother and aunt are arguing. However, the movie’s allegation of Lennon’s incestuous feelings is only based on one brief recording by Lennon after he had gone through Freudian psychological therapy. Also, in actuality, Lennon apparently began visiting his mother and her other family when he was 11, not 14 as the movie says. NOWHERE BOY contains plenty of strong obscenities and a lewd encounter between Lennon and his girlfriend.