Release Date: July 29, 2005
Starring: George Carlin, Whoopi
Goldberg, Drew Carey, Phyllis
Diller, Eric Idle, Billy
Connolly, Bob Saget, Susie
Essman, Gilbert Gottfried,
Kevin Pollack, Paul Reiser,
and Robin Williams
Rating: Not Rated
Runtime: 89 minutes
Director: Paul Provenza
Executive Producer: Paul Provenza and Penn
Producer: Peter Adam Golden
Address Comments To:Jeff Sackman
155 Avenue of the Americas, 7th Floor
New York, New York 10013
Phone: (646) 293-9400
Fax: (646) 214-7907
The clean parts of the joke include the opening and the punchline. The basic joke opens with a man coming into a talent agent's office and telling him, "Have I got a family act for you!" After the man describes all sorts of vile, offensive acts, which may last only a minute, or a whole half hour or more, the agent asks, "What's the name of the act?" "The Aristocrats," the man replies proudly.
The two people behind this vile movie are Penn Jillette of the comic magic act of Penn & Teller and his close friend Bill Provenza. Penn Jillette is a strong secular humanist who hates Christianity. In his public appearances, he frequently makes up the worst sort of lies and distortions about Christianity (including Mother Teresa's ministry to the poor and dying), often in an obscene, mocking way.
In the movie and its production notes, Jillette and Provenza give two main reasons for making the movie:
1. To show the art of total improvisation, in an informal atmosphere.
2. To call attention to questions of decency and censorship by showing that true freedom of speech means that there should be virtually no constraints, legal or otherwise, on offensive speech. Thus, serious discussion of ideas requires the freedom to talk really dirty.
In the movie, comedian George Carlin gives a weak defense of being able to defy boundaries, to push the envelope in everything, but most of the comics are just joking around, and some are much more offensive than others. For instance, although Tim Conway appears in the movie, he avoids any obscenity whatsoever. The offensive parts of the movie, however, contain the most vile, disgusting and evil video recordings ever made. Sadly, Bob Saget, the family-friendly comic of TV's FULL HOUSE and the original host of AMERICA'S FUNNIEST VIDEOS, tells one of the most revolting, sadomasochistic versions of the joke.
Dr. Ted Baehr, publisher of MOVIEGUIDE®, notes that Herbert Marcuse, the Marxist college professor who helped lead the student protest movement in the 1960s and influenced most of today's self-described liberals and "progressives," once said, "Language is a weapon." In this movie, the filmmakers are using language as a weapon against decency, respect, thoughtfulness, and kindness. Thus, THE ARISTOCRATS is one of the worst, most despicable secular humanist movies ever made. Some of the clean parts of the movie are indeed funny, but only individuals of sick minds will find the obscene parts funny, not to mention two brief scenes mocking Jesus Christ and clergymen.
To his credit, Dick Smothers doesn't find the joke funny when he is told it for the first time by his brother, Tom Smothers. Woefully for America's film community, Dick Smothers would have been in the minority at Robert Redford's 2005 Sundance Film Festival, where this movie reportedly was a smash hit. Clearly, the release of THE ARISTOCRATS marks a new low among America's cultural elite, where too many people, including members of the Supreme Court, have confused America's traditions of Liberty with Licentiousness. Such thinking not only marks a new low in decency, it's also a new low in irrationality and outright stupidity.
THE ARISTOCRATS is one of the worst, most despicable movies ever made. Some of the clean parts of the movie are indeed funny, but only individuals of sick minds will find the obscene parts funny, not to mention two brief scenes mocking Jesus Christ and clergymen. Not all of the comics engage in the vulgarity. One of the two main people behind this movie is the comic magician Penn Jillette of Penn & Teller, a strong secular humanist who often publicly attacks Christianity in the most vile manner.