Based on the children's book series, the movie MADELINE brings to life the story of a precocious girl Madeline, her school mates, their benevolent nun teacher Miss Clavel, and the owner of their school, the sourpuss Lord Covington. Weaving four of the books together for the movie, the ultimate story is whether or not Lord Covington will sell the school. Very moral with prayers and thanks to God, this movie will appeal to girls.
(C, BBB, L, V, M) Mild Christian worldview with Christian prayers & thanking the Lord & many moral elements including love, patience, understanding, perseverance, & asking forgiveness; 2 uses of the word "damn," 4 mild French obscenities & a few name-callings; no violence but some action including girl falling into river & girls run away from mice; no sex; no nudity; no alcohol use; no smoking; and, miscellaneous immorality including girl kidnapped, boy kicks over statue, man steps in dog excrement, girl threatens to run away, a minor element of false religion, & some lying rebuked.
The book MADELINE was first written and illustrated in 1939. About “an old house in Paris all covered with vines,” and its most famous inhabitant, the orphaned redhead Madeline, this classic children’s book and its sequels have sold more than 15 million copies worldwide. Now, the movie version brings to life this story of a precocious girl (Hatty Jones), her friends, a benevolent nun named Miss Clavel (Academy Award winning Frances McDormand), and the owner of their school, the sourpuss Lord Covington (Nigel Hawthorne).
The script weaves four of the six Bemelmans books (MADELINE, MADELINE AND THE BAD HAT, MADELINE’S RESCUE, and MADELINE AND THE GYPSIES) into a new story set in the mid-1950s. At the start of the movie, Madeline crumples over in pain and is whisked off to the hospital where she loses her appendix but gains an awesome cure. On her return to the school, all the girls want their appendix out.
When Madeline opposes the evening’s dinner because it is a chicken that she met earlier in the day alive, Lord Covington takes Miss Clavel aside and tells her he is going to close the school. He doesn’t give her a reason, but the audience knows he is suffering over the recent death of his wife. When Lord Covington, or Lord Cucuface as the girls calls him, begins to show off the house to potential buyers, including an Indian dignitary couple who states that the house has good “Karma,” Madeline masterminds a plan to scare them off. Madeline tells Pepito, the devilish son of the Spanish Ambassador who moves in next door, that he needs to be very quite when the house is being shown. Naturally, Pepito makes a lot of noise, with firecrackers, because he is a bit of a trickster. The girls are thrilled, but Lord Covington is not amused.
Madeline and the girls take a walk through Paris. Madeline falls into the Seine river, but a dog rescues her. The dog comes around later, so the girls name her Genevieve and hide her in the backyard tool shed.
When Pepito’s shifty tutor, Leopold, takes him to the circus, Madeline discovers his plot to kidnap Pepito with the aid of bumbling circus performers known as the Idiots Popopov. When Madeline decides to run away with the circus because she is losing her home, she is kidnapped with Pepito. Miss Clavel comes to the rescue, but Madeline and Pepito use their wits to escape. Finally, using her childlike clarity to see into the aching heart of Lord Covington, Madeline makes a touching, last-minute effort to save the school.
This movie is very innocuous and has many moral elements. Miss Clavel prays before dinner and before bed. She tells Leopold, who seems at one point to be getting a little fresh, that she prays on her day off. Madeline can be seen as a little rebellious, but she is more precocious and active than rebellious. She has a good heart and doesn’t do anything explicitly wrong. In fact, she learns many lessons. Ultimately, she is very respectful of authority and demonstrates love to someone she has found hard to love in the past.
The Paris cityscapes are very beautiful. The acting is fresh, as is the music. Along the way, the story introduces the audience to some French history, French architecture and some fine art.
Because the screenplay is a mixture of four short Madeline stories, it isn’t very cohesive. Sometimes it is as if the unspoken narrator is saying, “and then the girls did this, and then the girls did that, and then they did this.” It is a stringing along of smaller incidents, with little main plot to drive the story forward. It is established that Lord Covington wants to shut the school down near the beginning, but few of the scenes attempt to bring resolution to this story. However, few girl audience members will care. Boys may be bored, as the action is very mild, and, after all, the protagonists are girls who are “cute as a button.”
This movie easily could have been rated G with the removal of two uses of the word “damn.” It is very clean, very wholesome, very family friendly. Your daughter may love it. Your son may not. It is one of the few movies out this summer that has little, if next to no, objectionable material in it. Even Disney’s G rated MULAN can’t say that. Madeline is a fine effort at a fine and classic children’s series.
Since You’re Here…
We’re sustained by donations averaging about $25. Only a tiny portion of our readers give. If everyone reading this right now gave $7, our fundraiser would be done within an hour. That’s right, the price of one movie ticket is all we need. If Movieguide® is useful to you, please take one minute to keep it online and growing. Thank you.
Movieguide® is a 501c3 non-profit and all donations are tax-deductible.