"Mormon Drama About Fighting Hatred with Love"
What You Need To Know:
THE FIGHTING PREACHER has good production values, with the use of props, costumes and homes characteristic of the day. It’s also well-acted. People who have been bullied or persecution for their beliefs will relate to the movie’s story and characters. Except for some fighting and boxing, the movie is relatively clean. However, THE FIGHTING PREACHER has a strong, false Mormon worldview. People pray to Joseph Smith, who called himself the American Muhammad, instead of to Jesus Christ.
From director T.C. Christensen, THE FIGHTING PREACHER is the true story about Willard Bean, who became a champion middle-weight boxer in 1905. Ten years later, Willard and his new wife, Rebecca, are called by the Mormon Church to live on the Joseph Smith farm the church has just recently possessed. It is in New York where he and his family will become missionaries to the town for five years and re-establish the church in that area.
Since this is an already hostile area toward Mormons, Willard and his family face many challenges. Rebecca can’t find anyone to help her deliver her baby. She has intruders who lie to find their way into her home, only to taunt her with alleged lies about Joseph Smith. Willard gets harassed everywhere he goes, with men shouting in his face about what a horrible person he is for being a Mormon. At one point, he’s sprayed in the face with a hose because Mormons believe in “baptism by immersion.”
Tired of the bullying, Willard punches a man in the face and continues to punch others who do the same. At one point, he tells a group of men he’s going to strike them blind, then punches each eye and runs away.
All throughout these trials, however, Rebecca and Willard remain steadfast in their Mormon faith. When asked to acquire some land to build a church there in Palmyra, the harassment still continues. They pray and ask the Prophet Joseph to provide for them and protect them. Soon, a midwife knocks on their door and tells her she will help deliver their baby. When Rebecca delivers a beautiful baby girl, they name her Palmyra, after the town to demonstrate she’s been a gift from the Prophet.
Meanwhile, Palmyra is being bullied at school, and the teacher puts her desk in the far corner of the room away from the other children. The neighbors hate them, and the Beans are being asked to leave town. Questioning the Prophet about what he can do to spread the love He believes to those he meets, Willard returns to the boxing ring to show the town they shouldn’t mess with him. He invites the town to go into the ring with him and try to knock him out in three rounds.
Of course, the town loves a chance to knock out the “idiot” Mormon. However, they quickly realize Willard’s not someone to take lightly! Donned “the fighting preacher,” the town hates him more because they were defeated. With one act of kindness after another, Willard and family teach the town that sometimes the battles we fight can only be won by one thing – love. Slowly, as they learn to love the man whose views they don’t understand or agree with, a town’s lives are changed.
One of the biggest issues Christians will have with this movie is the overt Mormon theology pervasive throughout the movie. In one scene, mockers lie and ask to see Rebecca’s home to learn about Joseph Smith. She begins by saying their home is the place where Joseph Smith allegedly brought the plates he received from the angel Moroni. As they taunt her, she bears testimony that Joseph Smith was a prophet of Jesus, who preached a gospel of love and forgiveness. In fact, Joseph Smith called himself American Muhammad, invoking another murderous, cult leader. Rebecca also gives a testimony later on in the movie, where she recounts a vision where, after a long day of work, a handsome man was sent to her. The man visits Elder Talmidge and the two talk. When she says goodbye to him, she claims it’s Jesus who stands before her. Jesus says to her, “If you go about your work every day, as you have this day, you will be equal to it.” The end credits also highlight a verse from the book of Mormon, Jacob 7:26, which is about a Jewish Mormon sect in ancient times allegedly being cast out of Jerusalem and being hated by their fellow Jews. Although the overarching lesson about love and transforming a town through kindness is wonderful, moviegoers should be warned about the false theology espoused throughout the movie. Christians should exercise caution before viewing this movie. Not because of its interesting plot or clean content, but because of the false theology where Mormonism is equated with Historical, Biblical Christianity.
Lovers of historical novels and other historical TV shows like WHEN CALLS THE HEART will enjoy the historic setting of this movie. Set in New York in the early 1900s, people will love the costume design, props like wagons and horses, and the simplistic lifestyle that permeated the times. Rustic character homes with old wooden tables and chairs and potbelly stoves will transport any viewer back in time. The lush, rolling hills and beautiful trees accentuate the landscape and remind viewers of the location of the setting. David Shawn McConnell and Cassidy Hubert do a wonderful job portraying the real-life couple Willard and Rebecca Bean. Their onscreen chemistry is believable and the little girl who plays their daughter Palmyra is beautiful and also does a great job of playing an ostracized little girl whose loneliness drives her to show kindness in the midst of adversity.
THE FIGHTING PREACHER is a clean, family-friendly movie, with its major issues being the false Mormon theology and history and the violence. Because Willard is a boxer, there are many scenes not only of sports related violence, but also violence outside the ring. Willard punches many people in the face to protect himself and his family. Also, their 6-year-old daughter is shoved and ostracized by her teacher and peers. Any Christians who has been persecuted for the faith will be able to relate to the plot of THE FIGHTING PREACHER, but the false theology and false history make this movie deceptive and unacceptable.
Now more than ever we’re bombarded by darkness in media, movies, and TV. Movieguide® has fought back for almost 40 years, working within Hollywood to propel uplifting and positive content. We’re proud to say we’ve collaborated with some of the top industry players to influence and redeem entertainment for Jesus. Still, the most influential person in Hollywood is you. The viewer.
What you listen to, watch, and read has power. Movieguide® wants to give you the resources to empower the good and the beautiful. But we can’t do it alone. We need your support.
You can make a difference with as little as $7. It takes only a moment. If you can, consider supporting our ministry with a monthly gift. Thank you.
Movieguide® is a 501c3 and all donations are tax deductible.
Enjoy articles like this? Sign up for our mailing list to receive the latest news, interviews, and movie reviews for families: