"The Real Story of the Titanic"
Moral Americans, truth-seekers and enthusiasts may want to compare the very well crafted and performed British produced 1958’s A NIGHT TO REMEMBER to today’s TITANIC. Containing no sex, nudity or foul language, this documentary style movie doesn’t focus on any two passengers on the ship, unlike the fictional characters of TITANIC, but instead shows “slice-of-life” episodes of many of the main characters on board. The black and white photography doesn’t show some of the remarkable detail of the ship, but it is a fine format to demonstrate the bleak nature of the ill-fated voyage.
The movie does feature one character, Herbert Lightoller (Kenneth More), a second officer on the Titanic, who is first seen taking a train to the port where he explains to his fellow train travelers the unique and special features of the ship. As he boards the Titanic, the camera follows him for a while as he witnesses passengers settling into their quarters and the routine operations of the ship’s progress as it plows across the Atlantic. Unlike TITANIC, in A NIGHT TO REMEMBER, the Titanic takes only 20 minutes to hit ice. Then, the movie depicts the ensuing chaos on all decks, the trapped third class, the rush to the top decks, sleepy passengers who slowly crawl out of bed, the musicians playing softly in the background, and eventually the survivors watching from their lifeboats.
TITANIC and A NIGHT TO REMEMBER do share some common scenes, and it is very likely that TITANIC director James Cameron chose to simply replicate some of the more important scenes in A NIGHT TO REMEMBER. For example, in both pictures, Thomas Andrews uses the ships blueprints to explain to Captain Smith how the Titanic will sink, and Mr. Guggenheim is seen dressing up for his imminent death in both films.
A NIGHT TO REMEMBER, however, contains some key scenes, which are left out of TITANIC. These events actually happened and help make the true story stranger and more fascinating than Cameron’s fiction. This movie shows the deck of a mysterious ship just 9 miles away from the TITANIC. Its crew members wonder why the TITANIC is shooting off fireworks. History says that this ship, the Californian, had shut off its communication systems for the night. This movie also tells about how the Carpathian nearly burst its boilers steaming faster than normal to rescue the survivors of the TITANIC.
A NIGHT TO REMEMBER does have some minor inaccuracies. Contrary to popular opinion and the scenes in A NIGHT TO REMEMBER, the iceberg did not cause a large gash on the side of the ship. Instead, research tells us that the iceberg simply buckled in the sides, making rivets pop and letting water seep in through a series of small holes. This movie also shows the ship going down in one piece, but in fact, the ship split in two. Due to the fact that the undersea research was unavailable in 1958, these errors are forgivable and do not distract from the thrilling nature of the movie. A NIGHT TO REMEMBER doesn’t have romance or character studies like TITANIC, but it does have accuracy and morality. Though it doesn’t have the jaw-dropping special effects of TITANIC, its heroism in the face of tragedy is real. It is a fine and worthy alternative to TITANIC which contains some serious flaws for both the lover of history and the lover of morality.
(B, C, L, A, D, M) Moral worldview exemplifying pride coming before a fall, with Christian prayers & hymn singing; no foul language; mild violence including drowning deaths & other natural horrors; no sex; no nudity; alcohol use; smoking; and, mayhem & confusion
Moral Americans, truth-seekers and enthusiasts may want to compare the very well crafted 1958 British production A NIGHT TO REMEMBER to today's TITANIC. The movie begins with a second officer on the Titanic explaining to fellow travelers the unique features of the ship. The camera follows him as he witnesses passengers settling into their quarters and the routine operations of the ship's progress as it plows across the Atlantic. Unlike TITANIC, the ship in A NIGHT TO REMEMBER takes only 20 minutes to hit ice. Then the movie depicts the trapped third class, the rush to the top decks, the sleepy passengers crawling out of bed, the musicians playing softly in the background, and the survivors watching from their lifeboats. Unlike TITANIC, A NIGHT TO REMEMBER also shows important scenes on the rescue ships.
Containing no sex, nudity or foul language, this documentary style movie doesn't focus on any two passengers on the ship, but instead shows "slice-of-life" episodes of many of the main characters on board. The black and white photography is a fine format to enhance the bleak nature of the ill-fated voyage. A NIGHT TO REMEMBER is not a romance or character study, but it does contain accuracy and morality and a worthy alternative to TITANIC.